Homemade treats baked with love and care
Welcome to Michelle's Cakery n More, your local home-based bakery in Lake Mary, Florida. From custom celebration cakes to fresh cookies and brownies, every sweet creation is crafted to bring joy to your table.
Cupcakes & Pull Apart Cupcakes
Baked fresh to order in Lake Mary, our gourmet cupcakes combine light, tender sponge cakes with silky buttercream swirls. From classic Madagascar vanilla and rich chocolate fudge to seasonal specialties, each dozen is thoughtfully crafted for birthdays, parties, or everyday sweet moments.
Cupcake & frosting flavors Specialty Cakes
Signature Cupcake Flavors $18 dz
Classic Vanilla or French Vanilla
Vanilla has a rich, creamy, buttery flavor with just the right touch of sweetness and a smooth vanilla finish. Its light, fluffy texture melts in your mouth
Decadent double chocolate
Moist, rich cocoa made with premium dark cocoa for serious chocolate enthusiasts.
Fresh Strawberry Cupcakes
Soft vanilla buttercream infused with homemade real strawberry reduction for a bright, fruity bite.
Zesty Meyer lemon
Sun-ripened citrus zest folded into a fluffy sponge that balances gentle tartness and sweetness.
Funfetti celebration
Buttery vanilla cake loaded with colorful rainbow sprinkles, perfect for kid and adult birthdays.
Spiced carrot cake
Tender crumb packed with fresh grated carrots, cinnamon, and nutmeg for comforting warmth.
Pina Colada
A deliciously moist, tropical-inspired cupcake bursting with the sweet, juicy flavor of pineapple and rich, creamy coconut. Topped with a smooth, fluffy coconut frosting, every bite delivers a refreshing taste of paradise!
Silky buttercream frostings
Vanilla bean buttercream
Whipped Swiss-style American buttercream scented with fragrant pure vanilla extract.
Whipped chocolate fudge
Silky, deeply satisfying chocolate frosting with a glossy finish and creamy texture.
Classic cream cheese
Tangy, rich frosting whipped smooth to accent red velvet, carrot, and fruit cakes.
Peanut butter swirl
Creamy roasted peanut butter blended into a fluffy frosting, beloved atop chocolate cake.
Specialty frostings & toppings
Salted caramel buttercream
Homemade slow-cooked caramel stirred into velvety buttercream with a touch of sea salt.
Real strawberry buttercream
Fluffy buttercream naturally colored and flavored with concentrated berry puree.
Cookies & cream
Finely crushed chocolate sandwich cookies folded into light vanilla buttercream.
Espresso mocha swirl
Freshly brewed espresso notes whipped with cocoa for an aromatic, grown-up finish.
Whipped Cream Frosting
Fresh and light sweet cream
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Buttercream Frosting
Brown sugar cinnamon frosting is rich, creamy, and irresistibly delicious, featuring the warm, comforting flavor of cinnamon blended with the deep, caramel-like sweetness of brown sugar.
Specialty Cakes
Red Velvet Cake $45 and up
German Chocolate Cake $50 and up
Cannoli Cake $60
Death by Chocolate Cake $45 and up
Strawberry Shortcake $60
Carrot Cake $45 and up
Mounds Cake $60
French Vanilla Fruit Sensation $60
Tier Cakes (2 or more) ask for pricing
Christmas Cookie Trays $48
3 lb of assorted cookies
Italian Ricotta Cookies
Coconut Macaroons
White Chocolate
Cranberry Biscotti
Peanut Butter Blossom
Raspberry Dream Cookies
Italian Anise Cookies
Italian Snowball Cookies
Freshly baked specialties
Whatever the occasion or craving, each item is freshly made in small batches with premium ingredients and meticulous attention to detail.
Custom cakes
Designed especially for birthdays, weddings, holidays, and milestones, combining stunning designs with incredible flavors.
Gourmet cupcakes
Fluffy, flavorful cupcakes topped with smooth swirls of buttercream, perfect for party platters or individual cravings.
Homemade cookies
Classic favorites baked golden and chewy, bringing that comforting taste of homemade baking straight from the oven.
Brownies & more
Rich, fudgy chocolate brownies and a revolving variety of delicious sweet treats tailored for dessert enthusiasts.
A glimpse into our sweet kitchen
Browse through our colorful gallery of customized cakes and handmade confections created for celebrations all across Central Florida.
"The birthday cake Michelle made for my daughter was absolutely breathtaking and tasted even better than it looked. Everyone wanted seconds!"
Sarah M., Lake Mary
"Michelle's brownies and cookies are hands down the best in town. You can really taste the love and quality ingredients in every single bite."
Katie, Oviedo
"Ordering was effortless and Michelle paid close attention to every detail of our event theme. Our dessert table was a complete showstopper!"
Jessica L., Heathrow
Ready to plan your next sweet moment?
Whether you need a custom centerpiece cake for an upcoming party or a box of fresh treats for the weekend, we are here to bring your vision to life.
Get in touch with us
Bakery location
Michelle's Cakery n More
Lake Mary, Florida
Serving Lake Mary and surrounding areas